Explore
Barnegat Light
Neighborhood summary
Vibe:
Historic, peaceful, and nature-forward. Barnegat Light blends vintage charm with modern touches and offers a laid-back coastal lifestyle. Homes sit on larger-than-average lots, and the town remains one of the quietest spots on LBI — perfect for those seeking tranquility and natural beauty.Best for:
Year-round residents, vacationers, and anyone drawn to fishing, boating, or the serenity of quiet beaches. It’s especially ideal for those who appreciate wide open views, easy bay access, and a slower pace.Average home price:
$1,885,474 — though homes can range from under $450,000 for some condos to $5,000,000+ for waterfront estates. The area includes mostly single-family homes, along with some duplexes, condos, and commercial properties.Views:
Excellent. Think panoramic sights of the Atlantic Ocean, Barnegat Inlet, Island Beach State Park, and Old Barney. Many properties offer breathtaking bay, ocean, and lighthouse views — a key factor that influences price.
Barnegat Light is where LBI slows down and life becomes more intentional. Tucked at the northern tip of the island, this bayside village moves at its own peaceful pace. Locals wake to the hum of fishing boats, savor sunsets over the bay, and know their neighbors by name. With wide beaches, nature trails, and a true sense of community, Barnegat Light draws those looking to reconnect with the simple joys of island living. Whether you're walking to Viking Village for fresh seafood or biking through quiet streets lined with coastal cottages, this part of LBI feels worlds away — in the best way.
Fun Fact: Barnegat Light has a separate zip code (08006) than the rest of the island (08008). This is one of many nuances to this local market!
Barnegat Light real estate market
There are many cape cod & victorian style homes remaining in this section of the island
Oceanside lots are typically 50 wide x 125 feet deep
Generally speaking, buyers have been paying 96.6% of listing price when purchasing
On average it took 54 days to sell a home in Barnegat Light while the remainder of the island took 75 days
Barnegat light homes showed amazing resistance through Hurricane Sandy
The market here is distinct, and local knowledge goes a long way. If you're considering a home in Barnegat Light, feel free to reach out—I'm happy to walk you through the area and help you explore your options. Start your search below or get in touch anytime!
History
Barnegat Light is one of the oldest settlement areas on Long Beach Island, first explored by the Dutch in the 1600s. Its name comes from a Danish word meaning “inlet of the breakers,” referring to the rough waters of Barnegat Inlet. These dangerous conditions led to the construction of a lighthouse in the early 1800s, later replaced by the current 172-foot Barnegat Lighthouse—designed by General George Meade and completed in 1859. Known as “Old Barney,” it was re-lit in 2009 after being dark since 1944.
The town began to take shape in 1881 with the Barnegat City Improvement Company, which laid out the current street grid. It became an independent borough in 1904 and changed its name from Barnegat City to Barnegat Light in 1948. Today, the town is known for its preserved dunes, peaceful atmosphere, rich fishing heritage, and iconic lighthouse.
Contact us
Long Beach Island is a unique place to live, work, and play, and finding the perfect home here takes a knowledgeable guide who understands the local market. Whether you're looking for a vacation home, an investment property, or a year-round residence, I have the local insight and expertise to help you navigate LBI's niche real estate market. I'm here to answer your questions, share my in-depth knowledge of the area, and help you make the best decisions. Reach out today, and let’s start finding your ideal property on LBI!